Resident Raises Concerns about Proposed Sewage Treatment Plant

North Whitehall Township supervisors heard more testimony Monday night on how well the Lehigh County Authority would manage a new sewage treatment plant -- and if it's needed.

Questions of whether North Whitehall Township really needs a new sewage treatment plant, and how well the Lehigh County Authority would manage a 200,000-gallon-per-day plant, came into play Monday as the township supervisors continued to hear testimony on the proposed project.

The LCA is seeking approval for a conditional-use variance to construct the plant on Jordan Road near the KidsPeace campus.

If granted, the enlarged capacity plant would replace the current 62,000-gallon-per-day plant now serving KidsPeace. In addition to serving KidsPeace, the new plant would handle treatment for a proposed Walmart, Lehigh Carbon Community College, Schnecksville Fire Company and residential connections from future customers as township development increases. Ultimately, it could handle up to 200,000 gallons of sewage per day.

The approximately 40 residents attending sat quietly listening to testimony, most of which came from Jeanene Bauer, an opponent of the expansion who lives on Jordan Road. She presented a total of 26 exhibits, many from the Department of Environmental Protection, citing numerous violations by LCA in running much smaller plants in the area, such as those on Sand Spring Road and Wynnewood Terrace in North Whitehall, and the Heidelberg Heights plant in neighboring Heidelberg Township, questioning the LCA’s ability to manage a plant the size of the one proposed in the township.

Bauer also talked about mechanical failures and malfunctions that could impact the Jordan Creek.

“Being relatively fairly new to the area, I didn’t know the roads,” she said. “So I drove the township and discovered just how big it is, and nowhere did I find an area suitable for a sewage treatment plant. The majority of the township’s 15,000 residents have on-site sewage, and in the permits issued in the past 5 ½  years, none have been for total replacement of a system; they have been for minor repairs. My question is, why build this plant in an area that doesn’t need it?”

Rebutting her testimony was Frank Leist, capital works manager for the LCA.

He spoke about how poorly run the Sand Spring, Wynnewood Terrace and Heidelberg plants were before LCA acquired them, and how the authority took steps to repair and correct problems and maintain each site.

But Bauer countered with reports from DEP citing violations at each since being taken over by the LCA.

At times, Leist appeared to lose his composure. When asked if he questioned the DEP findings, he responded, “I can’t speak for the DEP. All I can say is, we [LCA] strive for perfection, but it’s not always possible.”

Also giving testimony was Emmaus resident Janet Keim, vice president of the Little Lehigh Watershed Coalition and former Salisbury Township commissioner, who cited federal and state laws protecting the environment. She talked about the effects of siltation (pollution of the water from sediment) from upstream development on the Little Lehigh, saying that e-coli from animal and human waste have been detected in the water. She warned about the potential for a similar problem if the sewage treatment plant is not managed and maintained properly.

“I wouldn’t want to see happen to the Jordan what happened to the Little Lehigh,” said Keim. “The LCA should not be given any approvals until the problems with the Little Lehigh are corrected and it is restored to its former state.”

Following Keim’s testimony, township solicitor Lisa Young asked if anyone else had testimony to offer. No one else responded, and the record was closed to comment, at which time residents objected, saying they were there not to “give testimony” but to make comments. Young reiterated the record was closed.

“I thought that was the purpose of this whole thing,” said resident Charles Hoover. Again, Young said she had asked if there was any further testimony and no one responded. So the record was closed. “I’m not here to give testimony,” replied Hoover. “I just want to make a comment. Some of us didn’t know that [commenting was giving testimony]. Some of us aren’t lawyers,” he added.

That brought a series of objections from the floor until the supervisors allowed comments off the record.

The supervisors will make their decision within 45 days. Another meeting is scheduled for 7:30 p.m. on Sept. 18.

NWT September 11, 2012 at 04:37 PM
sounds like Charles Hoover is a complete and utter idiot.
tamarya September 11, 2012 at 05:27 PM
I could see having water facilities treating water so every home has safe water. I know we have a private well and the way this water looks and tastes I would have no one drinking it, so far we had no issues bathing with it, however it does discolor clothing and the iron count is so high when you fill the bathtub it is nothing but brown colored. However the septics can be maintained through regular pumping, both here and where my grandfather lives it is required by the townships every 3 yrs and I know for my grandfather in almost 50 yrs never had an issue with the septic, even with city water.
Michaelyn Mohr September 11, 2012 at 05:28 PM
When these hearings began the Board of Supervisors told residents who tried to comment that it was not "the time for comments". Residents, they said, would be given opportunity to "comment". Mr. Hoover did not WANT to testify,nor ask questions of any of the witnesses. After each witness testified, the solicitor asked if anyone had "QUESTIONS" for the witness before they were excused. Mr. Hoover had no questions for the witnesses, he only wanted to comment and was never given that opportunity, even though his hand was raised, he was ignored by the Board.
tamarya September 11, 2012 at 05:28 PM
So I agree the sewer plant is not needed.
Anne Miller September 11, 2012 at 05:59 PM
I totally disagree ... your comment is inappropriate ...
Donald Driver September 11, 2012 at 06:26 PM
perhaps if mr hoover had been more involved with his community he would understand how a zoning board is basically a judicial arm of the township and EVERYTHING is testimony, dont act all concerned when you dont even know how things work in the township, what a silly goose
Jeanene Bauer September 12, 2012 at 01:13 AM
Hello. To correct statements within this article: I did not drive around the township, google maps was used to plot the 322 permit sites. I was, however and remain amazed by the open space in the North / Northeastern areas of NWT, Riverview, Range and Manor Rds...beautiful. Over the last five and one half years, 322 Sewer Permits were issued in NWT - 16 of those were within the service area of the proposed Sewage Treatment Plant. NOT ONE of the 16 PERMITS was for a system replacement; every one was for a simple baffle repair. The Sewer Permit History clearly reflects the glaring lack of need for a sewage treatment plant in the proposed area. Lastly, there are several suitable areas within the township for a new, STP. The Jordan Road site is not one of them. What kind of Supervisors, and Solicitor, would approve the construction of an unnecessary sewage treatment plant within a residential community?
Earnie Schneck IV September 12, 2012 at 01:30 AM
all those areas that are beautiful and open space? owned by Jaindl and destined for housing one day, most likely just like your precious little house was once open space. Where would you put the sewage treatment plant? NIMBY???? Do you know how to site a sewage treatment plant?? These plants are not located willie nilly, a lot of planning and due diligence with elevation, contours and accessibility are required. past needs are not indicative of future needs or most of NWT would be open space today, like the old timers wanted it, but no developers built up schnecksville, heck remember when there was no major grocery store anywhere near schnecksville? probably not because those conveniences were there when you immigrated into the area, am i right?
Earnie Schneck IV September 12, 2012 at 01:32 AM
exactly, thank you, wish more of these newbies who are so NIMBY would atleast show up for meetings occasionally until they wait to the last minute and have no clue as to how the process works, the lack of interest until NIMBY starts is downright sickening
Earnie Schneck IV September 12, 2012 at 01:34 AM
probably an out of towner who moved in and now is against everything that he was before he entered the area, Another NIMBY guy who doesnt realize most people did not want him or any other newbies coming to the area years ago, I laugh out loud at these people


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something